University of Michigan punishes professor for boycotting Israel

  • 1 week ago
  • 149

University of Michigan students show support for Israel on campus, 11 October (MEE/Graham Liddell)

Professor John Cheney-Lippold refused to write letter of recommendation for student planning to study in Israel

Free discourse and Palestinian backing bunches have upbraided the University of Michigan for denouncing an educator who declined to compose a letter of proposal for an understudy hoping to think about in Israel. 

John Cheney-Lippold, a partner educator of American culture, had consented to compose the letter, however later declined in the wake of finding the understudy was intending to contemplate in Tel Aviv. The educator is occupied with a scholastic blacklist of Israel in the midst of its human rights maltreatment against Palestinians. 

"I am extremely sad, however I just checked your first email half a month back and passed up a key detail," Cheney-Lippold composed the understudy, Abigail Ingber, in an email a month ago. 

"As you may know, numerous college divisions have promised a scholarly blacklist against Israel in help of Palestinians living in Palestine. This blacklist incorporates composing letters of suggestion for understudies intending to ponder there." 

On Wednesday, the Detroit News revealed that the college would not give Cheney-Lippold his yearly legitimacy based increase in salary for this scholastic year and will solidify his holiday for the following two years. 

The daily paper announced that the college likewise undermined to flame the teacher on the off chance that he carries on correspondingly later on. Cheney-Lippold is tenured, which means he can't be sacked, missing of a noteworthy offense. 

"Your direct has missed the mark regarding the college's and school's desires for how LSA (College of Literature, Science, and the Arts) staff associate with and treat understudies. This letter is a solid cautioning that your conduct in this condition was improper and won't go on without serious consequences," read a letter from the college to Cheney-Lippold, acquired by Detroit News. 


Palestine Legal, a Chicago-based backing gathering, pummeled the college for training the teacher. 

Radhika Sainath, a staff lawyer with the gathering, noticed that the University of Michigan is an open organization that may not lawfully control free discourse. 

"In opposition to the college's position, teachers have the privilege to decay to compose letters for various reasons, including their political perspectives about foundations complicit in human rights mishandles," Sainath said in an announcement. 

"There is no First Amendment special case for Israel. In singling out supporters of Palestinian rights for restriction, the University of Michigan is abusing free discourse and scholastic opportunity standards to which it is lawfully bound." 

The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) development called the college's choice "disgraceful". 

Hatem Abudayyeh, a prime supporter of the US Palestinian Community Network, adulated Cheney-Lippold's position. 

"It's the best activity," Abudayyeh told MEE on Thursday. "It's precisely what the scholarly blacklist was set up for. Palestinians, I can't represent every one of them, however I'm certain most by far of us in the US and over the world, are stating: 'Praise to him'. We express gratitude toward him and we bolster him." 

Palestinian rights advocates on the University of Michigan grounds coursed an announcement backing Cheney-Lippold a month ago. 

"Educator's [sic] ought not be subjected to any of this for practicing their entitlement to have political perspectives, decline to compose letters of proposal, or take part in scholastic blacklists against establishments complicit in human right infringement," the announcement said. 

It was sent to understudies and employees to add their marks to it. 


Understudies Allied for Freedom and Equality (SAFE), the fundamental star Palestine understudy aggregate at the University of Michigan, additionally upheld John Cheney-Lippold's choice. 

"We bolster and insist Professor John Cheney-Lippold's entitlement to blacklist Israel," SAFE said in an announcement in September. "His activities are the equivalent requested by Palestinian common society, and serve to name and oppose powers submitting human rights infringement. To rebuff Professor Cheney-Lippold for his activities would reduce his very own scholarly organization." 

Pro-divestment students hold signs against silencing them at student council meeting at University of Michigan, November 2017 (MEE/Ali Harb)

Prior this week, the Washington Post detailed that a second educator likewise declined to compose a letter of proposal for an understudy hoping to contemplate in Israel. 

Correspondingly to Cheney-Lippold, Lucy Peterson, a showing colleague at the University of Michigan, had consented to compose the letter before discovering the understudy's Israel designs. 

"I'm sorry to the point that I didn't request that before concurring compose your proposal letter, however I deplorably won't have the capacity to compose for your benefit," Peterson wrote in an email to the understudy, Jake Secker, as indicated by the Post. 

"Alongside various different scholastics in the US and somewhere else, I have swore myself to a blacklist of Israeli foundations as a method for indicating solidarity with Palestine." 

'Personal views'

On Wednesday, University of Michigan President Mark Schlissel tended to the occurrences inside the setting of protestations about enemy of Semitism on grounds. 

"Withholding letters of proposal dependent on close to home perspectives does not live up to our college's desires for supporting the scholarly goals of our understudies," he wrote in an announcement. 

"Lead that abuses this desire and damages understudies won't go on without serious consequences and will be tended to with genuine outcomes. Such activities meddle with our understudies' chances, abuse their scholastic opportunity and double-cross our college's instructive mission." 

Schlissel additionally reported that the school intends to make a staff board to "look at the crossing point between political idea/belief system and employees' obligations to understudies". 

On Thursday, graduate understudies flowed a letter communicating alarm at the college's measures against Cheney-Lippold. 

Signatories to the letter say the case "sets a disturbing, stressing, and risky point of reference for impinging on the secured political discourse and activity of representatives of the college". 

"Also, we express help for Lucy Peterson's choice to decline to compose a letter of proposal for comparative reasons, and we contradict any examination or disciplinary move that may be made against her," the letter peruses. 

Schlissel's office did not restore MEE's ask for input. 

Anti-BDS campaign

The University of Michigan's turn against educators who blacklist Israel comes in the midst of a forceful battle against BDS that commentators say damages the right to speak freely. 

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has cautioned of an "exasperating flood of government-drove endeavors to stifle the discourse of individuals on just a single side of the Israel-Palestine banter". 

In excess of 24 states have passed laws that would punish elements that blacklist Israel, albeit government judges have discovered enemies of BDS enactment in Kansas and Arizona to be illegal. 

Prior this year, Trump deputy Kenneth Marcus was affirmed as leader of the Office of Civil Rights at the Department of Education (DOE). Marcus, a wild ace Israel advocate, had sued scholarly establishments for boycotting Israel. His arrangement raised feelings of trepidation about the possibility of controlling understudies disparaging of Israel. 

Abudayyeh, of the US Palestinian Community Network, said the solid push against BDS is confirmation of its viability. He said while the crackdown on free discourse against the Israeli occupation is disturbing, it has not disheartened activists. 

"We are as yet sorting out emphatically in help of Palestinian rights, even with these allegations and even with these enemy of blacklist laws," he said. 


"The end here is this is what is not out of the ordinary when your development is making progress, when you're pushing ahead, when you're being compelling and impactful. We need to anticipate that that there's going will be suppression. That is the thing that occurs in this nation verifiably."